The Disclosure Dilemma: Are Clients Required to Reveal Non-Financial Convictions to Their Accountants?

Cover Image for The Disclosure Dilemma: Are Clients Required to Reveal Non-Financial Convictions to Their Accountants?

| Elaine Jackson

As the world of accounting continues to evolve, accounting professionals and other designated persons are faced with an increasing number of ethical and legal challenges. One such challenge is the question of whether clients are required to disclose non-financial convictions to their accountants. This issue has sparked a debate among industry experts, with some arguing that full transparency is necessary for maintaining trust and integrity in the profession, while others contend that such disclosures may not be relevant to the services provided by accountants.

The importance of due diligence and compliance in the accounting profession cannot be overstated. Accountants are responsible for ensuring that their client's financial transactions are legitimate and adhere to all applicable laws and regulations. This responsibility extends to assessing the risk associated with a particular client or engagement, identifying potential red flags and taking appropriate action when suspicions arise. In some cases, this may involve conducting enhanced customer due diligence and periodically reviewing, a sequence of transactions.

The question remains: should accountants be privy to information about their clients' non-financial criminal convictions? Proponents of full disclosure argue that knowledge of a client's criminal history can help accountants better assess the risk associated with a particular engagement and make more informed decisions about whether to accept or decline a client. Furthermore, they argue that being aware of a client's criminal past can help accountants identify potential red flags and take appropriate action to protect themselves and their firms from becoming unwitting accomplices in illegal activities.

On the other hand, opponents of mandatory disclosure maintain that non-financial convictions may not be relevant to the services provided by accountants and could potentially lead to discrimination against clients with criminal records. They argue that accountants should focus on assessing the legitimacy of a client's financial transactions and adherence to relevant laws and regulations, rather than delving into their personal lives.

Currently, there is no explicit requirement for clients to disclose non-financial convictions to their accountants. However, accountants must remain vigilant in their efforts to identify and address potential risks associated with their clients and engagements. This may involve asking probing questions, conducting thorough background checks, and seeking expert advice when necessary.

In some cases, accountants may become aware of a client's non-financial criminal history through their own due diligence efforts or as a result of information provided by the client themselves. In these situations, accountants must carefully consider the implications of this information and determine whether it is relevant to the services they are providing. If a client's criminal history raises concerns about their ability to comply with financial regulations or suggests a heightened risk of illegal activity, accountants may need to take appropriate action, such as declining to act for the client or seeking additional guidance from legal or regulatory authorities.

Ultimately, the decision to disclose non-financial convictions to an accountant lies with the client.

As in every case, when taking on a new client or performing customer due diligence on existing clients, accountants must remain vigilant in their efforts to identify and address potential risks associated with their clients and engagements. By maintaining a strong commitment to due diligence and compliance, accountants can help ensure the integrity of their profession and protect themselves from becoming unwitting accomplices in illegal activities. 

If you require assistance or advice in relation to any of the above matters, please contact our team on 053 91 000 00 or email [email protected].

Image of Elaine Jackson

About the Author

As a member of our Practice Support team, Elaine’s focus is on providing firm’s with assistance and training in the following areas; Anti-Money Laundering, Audit Testing and Walk Through Procedures, Audit Planning and Efficiency, OmniPro Audit Working Paper Demos, Preparing for Monitoring Visits and Post Monitoring Visit follow-ups. Elaine has over 15 years Accountancy Practice experience which has provided her with a wealth of knowledge across all industries and sectors. Elaine is an AITI Chartered Tax Advisor, a Certified Public Accountant and holds a Diploma in Corporate Finance. In her previous roles, Elaine has experienced a number of ACA and ACCA monitoring reviews. This experience has provided Elaine with a great understanding and appreciation for the challenges facing Accountants in practice today. link to

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Cover Image for Red Flag Indicators and Suspicious Behaviours in AML

Red Flag Indicators and Suspicious Behaviours in AML

 

In the world of finance and accounting, anti-money laundering (AML) procedures are critica...

Cover Image for Forensic Accounting: Types of Engagement

Forensic Accounting: Types of Engagement

 

Forensic accounting is a specialised field of accounting that involves investigating finan...

Cover Image for SORP Reporting for Charities: Focus on Donated Goods, Services, and Legacies

SORP Reporting for Charities: Focus on Donated Goods, Services, and Legacies

 

SORP (Statement of Recommended Practice) reporting is pivotal in providing charity-specifi...